Perfect question...wow if we could get that info...it would be a great visual and we could scroll back in time to find which instruments were most accurate...or we could determine an MAE or MFE......but this piece of the puzzle may not be revealed to us, unless we send 50 bucks

But seriously Thanks Mr Pip for your free work and willingness to share in the open forums...I can imagine Mr Bear is contacting you just about now...I hope you get the project and we can be allowed to pay !

I might even buy an EA of this...because I do not have time to trade it manually, but if I did this might be what I would spend my time with....I think the EA would be awesome, but there is no free lunch folks...face it!

ES

now we need only the zigzag that draws all lines and we can backtest this strategy manually

Hi guys,


Brunite you're right, i made an EA that uses the original rules some time ago and tested exactly on that big down move of the market. You can see the picture of what the expert did.
Blue lines = good transactions
Red circles = pain, big pain. )

If anyone here has an ideea to filter those signals, Holy Grail will become real .

P.S As you can see i stoped the test before 9.02 but it made more pips than it lost. So, send ideas if you want to make it better.

Thanks, Zmax

Attached Images

tester.gif (61.8 KB, 904 views)

ES...

Do you really think it's a coincidence that Mr. Pip is over here on this thread? I've been lying back watching this thread and making only a few comments. I have my mind wrapped around this method for awhile now and it's my intensions to improve upon the indicators that we have now at our disposal.

I have learned that you do get what you pay for as I plan on putting up the money to take these indicators that potentially have flaws in the code and have them improved upon with Mr. Pip's help. I have some ideas that I would like to see coded into a high caliber EA. That's all for now.

Don

__________________

"A man wears one watch and can tell time. A man wears two watchs and doesn't know what time it is"

old chinese proverb.....

www.ForexRobotTrader.com

Note: 100% no loss is obtained when no type of stop loss is employed

I did the same changes for NonLagZigZag indicator and no yellow or orange arrows appeared

I will need to check this further because last night on GBPUSD the line moved and there were 2 valid short trades, both wins. First was sell at 2.0245 for 90 pips, second was sell at 2.0250 for 27 pips. I switch to 15 minute with pivots on chsrt for determining exit points. Entry on first trade was around camarilla H3 Short and exit at L3 Long, just below central pivot.

Robert

using HAS confirmation would have entered very late.
Same with other MAs like LSMA and HullMovingAverage.
Using candle rule would have misses both trades.
It does look like it is best to just follow the original rules for now.

Trades were entered on 1 hr

Robert

oh good at least i do not need to send YOU 50 bucks again!

ES

Since this is an open source thread I cannot prevent anyone from having anything I post here.

Robert

hi guys,
in Signal Bars
what is the meaning
PIPs to Open, Hi to Low, Daily Av?

Regards.

MrPip,


Please look at the picture i uploaded with my earlier post. The EA used original rules. Entry/Exit when arrow+nonlag show(directly), no trail/wave ride. In order to make it better it has to use a filter....i think. This is what i'm searching for since this thread started.

Thanks, Zmax