Hi " MrPip " ( Mr. Robert ),


Thank's for your explained. Back to that 2 chart & 2 system, in one's of the chart that I'm using the bounchingPipEA_mpowerV4 system was ENTRY Position and the other wasn't.
My question is :
1. Is that one's reason for you to release the bounchingPipEA_mpowerV41 ? Cause in the new release ( bounchingPipEA_mpowerV41 ) not ENTRY position at same time. I'm running the system's ( v4 & v41 ) in 2 chart but in the same pairs and same time.

2. I was running your bounchingPipEA_BigBear_v22 ( New release ) from you Sir' but I was got this trade; ( Maybe you can take look my chart ).

Attachment 44003

Why there's double OPEN Trade ?? Will you fixed this problem Sir' ?? ( please forgive me, cause I'm not a programmer. )


Thank you Sir' for your kindness and helping me to clearly this section. Really, I'm very interested this system and method.


Best regards,

ningtyas

I am not sure why two trades were entered. I will change the code to be certain that will not happen. I think this might have happened because the original code used variables set to true or false to determine if OK to trade. I will change the code to check for open positions for determining OK to open new trades.

BTW, it is dangerous to trade this on 15 minute timeframe without a filter.

There are no signals to sell GBPCHF on 30 minute or 1 hour chart.

Robert

Fixed. It does not open multiple trades on backtest.

Robert

Attached Files

bouncingPipEA_BigBear_v23.mq4 (24.1 KB, 568 views)

I still have multiple trades

__________________
Trading software for the online investor.
Increase your results dramatically by buying the right values at the right prices.

Hi " Mrpip " ( Mr. Robert ),


Thank's " Mrpip " for you clearly explained and you have DONE.
I'm trying for the first time when I get this Bouncing method and System's with 3 untill 4 TF. I'm running all of each the System's using TF 30, 1 Hr and 4 Hr ( 14 pairs ) to all version
the system's ( V4, V41 and the last BigBear_V2 with 15 TF ). Just want to CLEARLY your system's running WELL. ( Comparison result by all version that you
have done with your system ).

That's why like I said You're the one's of GREAT MAN is this thread and forum.

So, I'm testing your latest system BounchingPipEA_BigBear_v23 soon Sir' to get the comparison result.


Thank you "Mrpip" ( Mr. Robert ) for your kindness.


Best regards,

ningtyas.

Hi all,
I've been lurking around this thread trying to keep up with it's tempo. In the mean time been testing my own idea on daily charts (I wrote about it here much earlier).
I admire all the work put in by Mr.Pip, Nix and others in creating the EAs. I've downloaded a few versions and have some questions/requests:

One of first ones has the Heiken Ashi candles as a filter, and the latter once (supposedly working better) do not. How do I add them back, what code do I need to copy and paste and where?

I'm happy that the stochastic stayed as a filter because it is theseceond part of my system.

What do I switch off in the code for the EA NOT TO CLOSE ANY TRADES. I would like to close them myself (or move stops to trail etc manually).

What I would only need is for the ea to open trades based on ZZ, HA and stoch (and the size of equity), set the initial sl (without moving it) and let winners run for me to manage them. Can that be done?

The logic behind not closing trades is that the price trends much more over longer periods of time than what can be achieved by signals from zigzag alone.

Thanks in advance, kindest regards

From your screenshot, it seems your exit indicator leaves more pips on the table than the QQE cross dxtrade has discovered. Notice on the short position QQE keeps you in the trade a little longer. On the long position, it gets you out at about the same time.

It looks like to me that on the 1h the zigzag + pointer + NLD + QQE make a good entry.

however the ZZ +P + QQE is enough to filter on the 4hr.

I just found something pretty interesting...

I sat in on Igor's webinar this morning for his new (Z_o_R_R_o) system, which was awesome, but I was playing with the indicators tonight trying to make it work for the H1 tf, and found that setting the signal line indicator to method 1 looked like a great trade signal for H1... I added the zigzag-pointerV2.mq4 to see how it worked out and WOW!! It filtered out most false arrows. It looks great on the H4 also.

Trading just the signal line with the bar trend (Igor's Heiken), according to Igor's rules, keeps you in thru that long trend last month, filtering all the false arrows except 4, all profitable, the last being the reversal. Really would only need those 2 indicators. Compared to nonlagdots, this signal line on seems to be more consistent.

Just trying to contribute... newbie so please be nice...

Attached Images

	signal line h1.gif (33.8 KB, 961 views)
	signal line h4.gif (35.9 KB, 949 views)

So according to your 1st chart we would have exited our 1st short trade 4 times, 3 times with small profits (considering that we exited early enough to take them) and the 4th time for the real reversal. Right?
But then we didn't stay in the 1st short trade all the way down! Right?
Or am I missing something?