Hi "Mrpip" ( Mr. Robert ),

Thank you for your explanation. Will give me an explanation too for my chart Sir' ??

First of all, from begining the system is fixed, I'll trying soon. I will useing TF ( 30, 1Hr and 4Hr ) for the Bouncing V_4 and V_41. And want trying V_2 ( Basically method ) that you was fixed Bug and release. Cause' I'm very interested with this method and System. ( Thank you All for your contribution,
Mr. Bigbear, Forex11, Mrpip, Nix, and other people in this thread and forum. )

So why I want to asking you with your logic in the 2 system Sir' ??

Attachment 43980

Attachment 43981


My quetions is :

1. Why in that chart, the one's get ENTRY position and the other not yet ?? Am I missing one thing with your setting or logic that each system's that you want to make it ( I mean about the filter ) ???

Thank your soo much Mrpip for your kindness and explained.


Best regards,

ningtyas

Because in the first chart the QQE crossed and nonlagdot is blue.
In the second the QQE hasn't crossed yet.

I don't have this EA...so I'm not sure whether it takes these 2 conditions to enter...but looks like this.

Hi Mr. dxtrade,

Thank you for your explained, but please forgive me if I'm wrong.
You mean in the second chart the QQE was crossed but nonlagdot hasn't change ( be a blue ). I that what you mean Mr dxtrade ?


Thank's for your kindness,

ningtyas

yes, on the second chart the nonlagdot went blue but the QQE hadn't crossed yet. Then it crossed but the nonlagdot isn't blue anymore.

Just take the default settings. For exiting short position, wait for blue line to go up and through the channel line (see picture below). For exiting long position, wait for blue line to go down and through the channel line (see picture below). I pulled up a 1hr tf just to demonstrate both scenarios.

Hi Forex11,

While Igor may not have the best tact (which I think has a lot to do with his non-native english), I have to agree with him. Most system traders agree that for results to have meaning, you should have over 100 trades. When I did backtesting with this system, I went back 4 years. This system (when using the EA) only made money in the last year. If you start the EA and use data from, say 1/1/2004 to 1/1/2006, it is not profitable.

Now, having said that, that doesn't mean the system isn't profitable, or that it could not have been manually traded for profit in those back years. My concern is that this system may have just started working - quite well, mind you - when you started trading it. When MrPip has provided us with this EA, I was SO excited to see that from 1/1/2007 to 9/1/2007, this system made a buttload of money. But then when I advanced the start date further back, the profits started to shrink. Having manually traded this system when I found this thread in August (demo account.. ) - I couldn't believe how many pips I was getting.

BigBear provided some take profit points, which could also make this system profitable in those other years. I never tested it with take profit points.

I was wondering if you guys back tested this, and if you did, how far back you went? The other thing is - some systems just can't be mechanized. This system may work best when manually traded. There seem to be a few rules that are discretionary as far as exiting goes, and those can be difficult, if not impossible to code. I have yet to write a function called "humanIntuition" - although I could proabably make a fortune if I could.

Thanks,
burn0050

__________________
He who laughs last thinks slowest

Hi Mr. turnupvol,


How long you running test with your suggest that Indi, and how about the RESULT ??

Thank you for your kindness Sir'.

ningtyas

dxtrade
Is nonlagdot and QQE the only criteria for takin the trade for you, or do you also need the zigzag and pointer?

thx

Default setting in the EA is to only use nonlagdot with a wait of 3 candles. And that is not blue anymore so no trade.

Robert

Zigzag and pointer, and then filtered with nonlagdot AND qqe on 1H on EJ (SL 30) and GJ (SL 50).
Works fine for me. Till now
As exit I will try the qqe re-cross