Please include the following information in your post:
#1 Timeframe
#2 Broker
#3 Settings file if any was used
#4 Real or Demo account?
#5 Version of Phoenix used
#6 Phoenix mode used

#7 The detailed trading report uploaded. (right click transaction history and save)

We use these to analyze how well Phoenix is working, and the actual trade history is sometimes more important to developers than the final result.

If anyone is able to collect previous detailed reports and paste them all here so we can compare them more easily, that would be greatly appreciated.

Hi all,

as promised to Hendrick here are statements for week 13/17 Nov. 2006.

They are 3 demo mini-accounts on IBFX starting with USD 500, one for each mode.
I have seen that IBFX demo is very, very similar to live account. When I do not have a pair on play on demo and live phoenix enters the same time and same price (difference no more than 1 or 2 pips) on live and demo.

As often said mode 3 made a fantastic work on last 2 weeks. I made many mistakes with my live accounts switching from mode 3 to mode 2 to mode 1 and to mode 3 again. In that way I made some bad trades also closed manually but when 2 days ago I put again mode 3 on live account and left it working my account started to gain again.

Anyway please watch statements and make your considerations.

Bye!

Raf

Attached Files

Phoenix Statements week 13-17 nov.2006.zip (22.6 KB, 2604 views)

#1 Timeframe: M15?
#2 Broker: IBFX
#3 Settings file: Defaults?
#4 Account: Demo
#5 Version: 5.6.3
#6 Phoenix mode: 1,2,3
#7 Detailed report: 3 attached

Am I right about Timeframe and settings? Thank you very much for the reports!

#1 Timeframe: M15
#2 Broker: IBFX and FBFX
#3 Settings file: Defaults for Classic
#4 Account: Demo
#5 Version: 5.6.3 and P4 Contest
#6 Phoenix mode: 1
#7 Detailed report: zip containing 3 statements
-----------------

Installations
-----------------------
A) FBFX 5.6.3
B) FBFX 4Contest
C) IBFX 5.6.3
D) IBFX 4Contest

C and D were dropped mid week. D yielded no trades. C yielded reverse trades to A even though using same version with same settings (at least for the first 2 trades). Such oddity caused great concern. Seeing wierdness with IBFX, I decided to drop it. IBFX was a mini, FBFX was a standard account. Multiply IBFX gain/loss by 10x to get one-to-one P/L correlation.

Summary
--------------------
FBFX 5.6.3: 3 wins 1 loss, +$401.41 closed, -$144.24 open
FBFX P4Contest: 1 win 1 loss, -$646.20 closed, -$126.96 open
IBFX 5.6.3: 1 win 1 loss, -$55.30 closed, $0 open (multiply by 10x)
IBFX P4Contest: no trades placed

Note: The FBFX P4Contest trades correlate with the MQL4.com championship results over the same time period. Yes, there's slight price differences. But, entries are correlated.

Hope this analysis helps!

Bill

Attached Files

11-13 to 11-17.zip (20.1 KB, 563 views)

#1 Timeframe: M15
#2 Broker: FXDD
#3 Settings file: Defaults
#4 Account: Demo
#5 Version: 5.6.3
#6 Phoenix mode: 1
#7 Detailed report: 1 statements
-----------------

good resul for this week

giapel

Attached Files

11-17 nov 2006.htm (16.5 KB, 1001 views)

1 Timeframe: 15min,
2 Broker: Neuimex,
3 Settings file: Defaults,
4 Account: Demo,
5 Version: 5.6.3,
6 Phoenix mode: 1

Attached Files

Stat 171106.htm (16.9 KB, 703 views)

Yes, sorry....Pairs: GBPUSD, USDJPY, EURJPY and USDCHF

Timeframe=15mn
Pairs tested: usd/jpy, gbp/jpy, gbp/usd, eur/jpy
account= demo
version: 5.6.3
Phoenix mode= 1
Broker: FXlite

I'm sad that Hendrick is no more around but I understand very well. Good lock to you Hendrick and long life to Phoenix because this EA has very large potentiel.

Attached Files

Phoenix_5.6.3.zip (2.9 KB, 697 views)

I'm so happy to see everyone coming through so well! I need to post my own results as well so other people can see.

Billworld: that irregularity is my main concern. I am hoping that the consecutive trade filter will help filter reverse results. Since the indicators are based on the differences between values (moving average, etc), a small difference would yield a trade. The size of the values aren't checked, just their relative value. If the values aren't very strong one way or another, they may bounce back and forth quickly. A filter has been added in the 5.6.4 (you need to modify settings to activate it) to not trade on changing signals. Hopefully that will eliminate the kind of trade problems you saw.
More details in the Coding section...

#1 Timeframe: M15
#2 Broker: INTERBANK
#3 Settings file: Defaults
#4 Account: Demo
#5 Version: 5.6.3
#6 Phoenix mode: 3
#7 Detailed report: 1 statements

Mixed week...

Preparing a macro in Excel and will share when done :
Sort by pair and inside by date
TT pips by trades
Results by pairs : TT trades, TT wins (%) TT loss(%) TT pips Avg pips por trade
More results ? Let me know

Attached Files

Statement 17 nov.htm (34.4 KB, 853 views)