I would, if I could find the cyan versions it is referring to.
Any pointers?

Simba,
I've followed Ehlers for years, spent 100s of hours working with his stuff in Tradestation, more hours trying to digest his books and articles in TASC, modified his stuff aplenty ...and I could not give a reply nearly as good as the one you gave in post 21. I would not change a word of it.

- - -

Everybody,
Awesome thread!

Hi Dan ,

I would attach them if i had,but i deleted them from my computer ..you can find them at..(i believe this is the right webpage..if not,do a search for posts by damiani or damianifx in this forum since he has the link to his website in his posts)

www.damianifx.br

Hope this helps you
Regards
Simba

Hi Pecunia non olet,

Thanks,I am reddening,surely you could..
By the way I like your nickname,it is very appropiate for our profession..
And for many others too

Thanks again for your kind comments and Regards
Simba

Hello:

There is a code problem with the indicators posted by bluto, and also with Cyan indicators comes from Damiani directly.

I´m trying to cantact him. There is no a live or dead problem, the indicator will work good (?) anyway.

The quote from mql:

This are my attempts to clean the code of some version.

Unfortunately test cyber cicle takes a lot of time because not works with tester. Seems to be ok.

RVI comes by default with MT installation. Differences are minimal (really minimal). Seems to be ok.

Center of gravity: there are several versions, IMHO, Luis made the most close with Ehlers description, there is another one made by Rosh recently and is very good.

I don´t like the version of Fisher Transform, I prefer the one made by Igorad because IMHO is identical to Ehlers description.

I can´t fix the error with FishStoch, aka Fisher Transform for CCO, COGO or RVI.mq4
Maybe Igorad or Kalenzo can fix it.
The problem is if I remove the ArrayInitialize the indicator does not paint, if i donñt remove the Array I have the error.

Wake up all night try to find a solution was a waste of time.

Attached Files

	TSD_CyAn_4_Cyber Cycle.mq4 (3.5 KB, 371 views)
	TSD_CyAn_5_CG Oscillator.mq4 (3.2 KB, 361 views)
	TSD_CyAn_6_RVI.mq4 (3.2 KB, 347 views)

__________________

Elite Manual Trading | Portfolio | Calendar | Suggestions to improve the forum | My Blog

Remember: Signatures must have three lines as maximum

Hi Linuxer, thanks for explanations.

Do you think you could do us all a favor and, since you seem to have tested all of these great indicators, make a post with all the indicators (or links to them) that you consider final and ready to use? Plus a list of those that you think have bugs, so that someone who is able to fix them can do so?
I would really like to help but I'm not a very skilled MQL4 programmer nor a skilled interpreter of Ehlers science

Thanks very much

__________________
Malcik

My previous post have the indicators I´ve tested after a mini modification in the code to avoid the little error explained.


Anyway, CyberCicle have a bug. It works, but with some time the line becomes flat and you have to move between TF to display correctly.

COG you can use the posted version It´s ok, also I´ve checked with another 3 platforms.

You can use default MT RVI.

Fisher Transform or FishStoch have the inherent problem of cybercyle painting problem. You have to move between TF.

There are lot more indicator which attempts to duplicate what Ehlers wrote for Tradestation.
Some of them are clones, other are a completely disaster.

You need to be careful (I guess is the 50th time I said the same) and before trust blindly make a hard comparison.
If you don´t have the book or article in where the indicator is explained. And/or you don´t know anything or a little about MQL4 do what I do: compare with a another 2 or 3 charting software (eSignal, TS, Teletrader, VTS, etc).
Because almost 80% of this indicator are published in SFO or S&C magazines with the code cheeked by the makers.

Look at the StochRSI for MT, no one of the versions for MT are ok. However the Instantaneous Trend Line in Metaeditor Database it´s ok.

iFish made by Kalenzo is master piece.

etc etc etc.

__________________

Elite Manual Trading | Portfolio | Calendar | Suggestions to improve the forum | My Blog

Remember: Signatures must have three lines as maximum

I cannot get to the link, it tells me its a BAD GATEWAY, those bad URL messages...

http://www.damianifx.com.br/

http://www.damianifx.com.br/indicators.php

http://damianifx.blogspot.com/

__________________

Elite Manual Trading | Portfolio | Calendar | Suggestions to improve the forum | My Blog

Remember: Signatures must have three lines as maximum

Thanks buddy, I'll check 'em out!