Welcome to Forex-TSD!, one of the largest Forex forums worldwide, where you will be able to find the most complete and reliable Forex information imaginable.
From the list below, select the forum that you want to visit and register to post, as many times you want. It’s absolutely free. Click here for registering on Forex-TSD.
Exclusive Forum
The Exclusive Forum is the only paid section. Once you subscribe, you will get free access to real cutting-edge Trading Systems (automated and not), Indicators, Signals, Articles, etc., that will help and guide you, in ways that you could only imagine, with your Forex trading.
Elite Section
Get access to private discussions, specialized support, indicators and trading systems reported every week.
Advanced Elite Section
For professional traders, trading system developers and any other member who may need to use and/or convert, the most cutting-edge exclusive indicators and trading systems for MT4 and MT5.
I have downloaded your indicator and am testing it at the moment against the KUP v82 and Search_Pattern_v6.
I like you indicator but it seems to find less patterns compared to the other two. I am using the smaller of the minswing files but when comparing your indicator against the standard Zig Zag indicator the swings are I feel still wide.
I think that that there would be an improvement if the search swing was reduced maybe to match the standard zig zig indicator.
I am going to try and have a play around but would be interested in your thoughts.
hello,this is my first post. After browsing the front end of this thread going into 2007, WRR created a Zup indicator for gartley patterns. without having to read every page can someone direct me to the one everyone is using as of now? Whatever the version, as long as it works and shows the patterns. As well can someone perhaps tell me how to load it into MT4? Any help would be appreciated.
neal
hello,this is my first post. After browsing the front end of this thread going into 2007, WRR created a Zup indicator for gartley patterns. without having to read every page can someone direct me to the one everyone is using as of now? Whatever the version, as long as it works and shows the patterns. As well can someone perhaps tell me how to load it into MT4? Any help would be appreciated.
neal
Hi Neal, I assume you are referring to the wrr_zup_info indicator, it is available at http://www.forex-tsd.com/216145-post254.html. Keep in mind that this indicator does not display the actual pattern, it simply adds additional information to the pattern identified by ZUP, and it has pattern alerts. You will also need a ZUP indicator, they can be found here Harmonic Trading.
Personally, I use zup 82 along with WRR_ZUP_INFO for emailing out alerts.
I have downloaded your indicator and am testing it at the moment against the KUP v82 and Search_Pattern_v6.
I like you indicator but it seems to find less patterns compared to the other two. I am using the smaller of the minswing files but when comparing your indicator against the standard Zig Zag indicator the swings are I feel still wide.
I think that that there would be an improvement if the search swing was reduced maybe to match the standard zig zig indicator.
I am going to try and have a play around but would be interested in your thoughts.
Adey
Hi forexadey,
Some comments that may help to clarify your doubts:
1. Indi looks for book suggested relationships.
2. You may use delta parameter to define the calculation precision you like: dextMaxDeviation parameter. By default set to 10%=0.1, but even this can be too high from what i am hearing from years experienced harmonic traders.
3. See bextCheckMultiZigzags, dextHL_MultiZZMinSwingRange and iextHL_MultiZZMinSwingNum in the documentation. This is multizigzag functionality that allows you to scan the chart not only with exact swing (as defined in txt), but also ones in the defined range.
Feel free to ask for details and let me know your comments when you finish your tests,
Cheers,
kor4x
1. No need to change the digits in the txt for 5 digits brokers. All is recalculated automatically.
2. I am also getting the error you mention "Not enough MaxBars specified to calculate ZigZag with 7 points". This happens to me when MT4 is missing some data and has to download. Anyway, i will check it, as number of people reported same problem. Thanks.
kor4x
1. No need to change the digits in the txt for 5 digits brokers. All is recalculated automatically.
Hi Kor4x,
I changed the digits in korHarmonics_MinSwingDefaults.txt a while back and it fixed the problem for me. Are you saying this is wrong? As an example, here is what I get on USDJPY
Default setting "USDJPY;2;20;40;70;130;200;350;650;1200;2500". I get the error. kor-error.gif
Increasing the digits by 1 (as I have a 5 digit broker) to "USDJPY;3;20;40;70;130;200;350;650;1200;2500". It seems OK. kor-ok.gif
Have I inadvertently messed up the pattern recognition?
@retsel
Do not change the digits. It's OK, it recalculates automatically for 5 digits platforms.
Instead:
1. change the defaults: from "USDJPY;2;20;40;70;130;200;350;650;1200;2500".
to smaller values (try half maybe). The default values seem to be too high.
2. You can also change the iextMaxBars to higher value to avaid the error, if you still want to stay with the same swing size.
Depends a bit what you want to achieve.
Anyway, thanks for letting me know, i will decrease the values in the next release.
I am not using USDJPY and the defaults seem to be too high.
kor4x
Linear Mode
