See this thread from the beginning. For example, Bruno tested Alex's MandarineXL v0.2 during the 11 days. There are a lot of Statements posted here about this version of Mandarine
http://www.forex-tsd.com/showpost.ph...9&postcount=45
As I know he used H1 with default settings on 4 main pairs.

This is MandarineXL v0.2
http://www.forex-tsd.com/473-post8.html

Beluck's Mandarine is here http://www.forex-tsd.com/showpost.ph...9&postcount=10

And all the mandarines with EAs are located here http://www.forex-tsd.com/expert-advisors-metatrader-4/

But as I know both of them are working without any indicators. You may use T3MA indicator and signal indicator just to check something but for Beluck's mandarine only.

thanks a lot for the links, in fact the mandarine version 2 is profitable as i am forward testing it, just want to know how it works, so we can check it manually.

Those Mandarines are so different that can not be compared even.

Alex's Mandarine v2 is good for backtesting and very easy/understandable with settings. And it is profitable. Easy to test let's say.

Beluck tried to create his Mandarine fully followed the original idea and because of that his Mandarine is more complicated and having some difficulties in selecting the right settings. But is it profitable as well (I tested it for some period of time) and ... more comfortable: S/L is moving in very comfort way, we may attach two indicators to the charts and EA will fully follows the indicators' signals etc.

Hello,

I stop test it EA Mandarine because it loses what it gained the previous week. for the statements, they were removed by errors with other reports.

Beluck's Manradine EA (therre are 2 EAs on this section so it is Beluck's version). Default settings. Forward testing results.

Attached Files

mandarine.zip (45.3 KB, 83 views)