Quote:
Originally Posted by zupcon
This would seam to be the complete opposite of whats actually required !
Vendors with unproven products get complete control over their threads. This will no doubt be abused. In order for the vendor to perpetrate their little scam, you get bombarded with requests from the vendors to protect them, by removing posts.
So the problems remain, and you create even more unpaid work for yourself !
Any attempts at serious evaluation of a product, gets split into a myriad of individual threads. Worse still the disruptive elements who cant post in the vendors thread, are completely free to disrupt the evaluation threads, which then turn into a free for all.
Although I can see how this might provide endless entertainment, I cant really see how any of this encourages collaborative development.
However I wish you luck  |
I already you got bombarded with requests during the 1 year already.
The problem is the following:
vendor is openning the thread. One member are bombarding him, his thread and his system with no oany technical manner. With very personal manner. And everybody forgot already aboyut what his system is about and so on.
Quote:
|
Vendors with unproven products get complete control over their threads.
|
Yes, you are right, complete controll. And complete responsibility.
And it will not be myriad of individual evatuating threads. And vendor will not control evaluating threads. It will be one evaluated thread per commercial vendor's thread. Let's evaluate the vendor from some distance and not helping the vendor to sell.
Example with Steinitz. If he posted weekly repeated statements and many people like it so you can open evaluated thread and say about it. Many memebrs will join if they want. Steinitz will join. I will join. And Steinitz thread will be moved to 'Raw Commercial Ideas' section to improve the mistake. If not improve - will be deleted. It is very easy going and with no any noise on the forum.
If someone wants to promote something - go to evaluation thread. If critics - evaluation threat. Clients asking for money back - evaluation thread.
I will delete commercial thread not based on someone's thinking and not based on my personal thinkings. It will be based on evaluation thread.
Evaluation threads will not be deleted.
If someone posted bad evaluation for some person based on his age (it was discussion about Steinitz age) and this person did more than 2 pages about it - so this person will be banned. Because discussion about someone's age is not related to any evaluation.
If the vendor did not give any information to be evaluated so his commercial thread will be deleted.
it is very easy, no noisy and with no problem.
I am spending now more than 4 hours per day for commercial section sorry.
I want to spend less than 1 hour per day.
If no one evaluate some system so I am having the right to evaluate.
It may be like that: "evaluation of ... system.
1 (and last one). Because no any information presented by vendor on his commercial thread for evaluation so his thread will be deleted. Anything?"
That's all.
It is responsibility of the vendor to present the information, or statements or any. If the system is good evaluated with some critics and good posts as well so it will help the vendor a lot as it will be the other thread about his system.
It does not mean that all the scamms will be accepted to commercial section. It will be moderated in the same way as before.
And it will not be big discussion as evaluation section is moderated by posts now. It means that someone did one post and will wait for moderation. Next post - moderation. It will not be any discussion.
If everything will be fine so evaluation section will not be moderated at all.
Linear Mode
