what do you mean we don't have to CONTRIBUTE ????
you told me in private i HAVE to contribute to get any indicators (i only requested two)

I told you I would not have money till july 1st payday...but you said NO favors. In my country (USA) contributions are optional but one still qualify for the product, if thats the pitch.

Sounds like you are selling indicators if that's the case its no big deal just please be honest!

I'm not telling you should not sell them since you do have a talent. But your post seems misleading.

Please do NOT misquote me. Also private matters are supposed to be PRIVATE. The indicators you requested are part of an indicator file that I send out as a THANK YOU. I don't just send out 1 or 2 indicators.

You do NOT have to contribute. No one is forcing you to contribute. I have posted plenty of FREE indicators that you may download.

If you would like to make a contribution, feel free to do so. If you do, I will send you more indicators as a THANK YOU.

Does that make it clear?

Ok can you send me the following two indicators below? I am unable to contribute at this time, but I can (and will) in the future. The indicators below are not available in your thread to download (like others i have seen)


_TRO_HL_TRADE

_TRO_2_CANDLE_TREND


thank you

I already explained that to you.

my point exactly

have a nice day!

Hi TheRumpledOne,

First of all, I cannot understand why you posted your indicators here in Commercial Trading Systems and indicators folder if you are not selling them.

Correct me if I am wrong. Based on your remarks, I can only assume that one must contribute (in your word), pay or buy (in my word), if he or she wants indicators you posted like _TRO_HL_TRADE and _TRO_2_CANDLE_TREND.

I think you could just give the indicators first via pm or email, whatever, and get the thank-you contribution, unless you really want to sell them.

I am really thankful to you that you have shared lots of indicators you created. However, you are asking contribution, i.e. money, for the indicators posted here, and saying you are not selling but accepting thank-you contribution, in the Commercial Trading Systems and Indicators folder.

I hope I was wrong about understanding your words here and you are a true giving and sharing person. I will absolutely contribute, if you first share me the indicators and give me some time to test them. I give you my word.

Regards,
Longboy

I have searched his forum well but cannot find all those free indicators TRO has boasted.

Nor did it say to sign up first.

I REALLY do not appreciate having my time wasted.

What's going on?

newdigital told me that I had to post my "donation" indicators in the commercial section. I am not allowed to post of chart of them anywhere else on forex-tsd or I will get banned. So I am just following the rules of this forum as best I can.

If you look at the threads that I have started here on Forex-TSD, you'll find many indicators that I have posted including the source code.

I hope this clears up any misunderstandings.

I am not sure what forum you searched. Most forums require you to REGISTER and LOG IN before you can download.