Hi Nina, disappointing - but this is your thread so its your call, and like you say maybe there is something wrong here that is not obvious to others.

I & many others respect both Kale & Harold's input to trading we need all types of personalities here. I find Harold very direct but very helpful. Maybe just communication breakdown.

Can I ask simple question ? Do you agree or disagree that the thread has gone off purpose somewhat ?

By this I mean shouldn't we all be just sharing with new traders the basic catfx50 manual trading strategy that you posted - I mean its simple and successfull. Seems like people are getting bored waiting for signals and then posting non catfx50 related material this just confuses everyone and the thread is too big to follow for new starters.

I am not talking about improvements to the step stochs for instance, there is alsways some room for this I think - but all non CATFX50 related trade discussions should be posted elsewhere.

If you agree I would appreciate it if you made a clarifying statement to help get people back on the subject .

Regards

Hi, npj!

Look, catFX50 system is a winning one. You make money with it. You know my motto: FOCUS, PATIENCE AND DISCIPLINE. If people get bored waiting for signals, they should go to other threads and try to make a mix for their own.

I trade others systems too and I try to improve CatFX50 with it if I see it will do good for it. Trust me, when I really lose money, I do, is when I do not follow catFX50. I trade against me. Maybe is a luck of confidence, I do not know. Maybe I have an addiction and I need to trade. We should know ourselves better than we do.

But you are right, I'll be more strict now with non related catFX50 posts.

Nina

If anyone is trading these horrible conditions, according to rules we had a long signal on EUR /USD at 15:00. Technically ema 50 is below ema 100 / ema 120 so that would favour shorting - used caution and only 1 contract - it is currently has gone against us by 20 pips. Step stochs are still long....Price target = ema 100

Hi,

If we want eurusd and GBPUSD (?) up, we need USDCHF to lose clearly 1.2283.

Nina

Now it turned around in EURUSD. Cable might have been stopped out but this one was too far from the EMA anyway

I think the pivot line at 93 might be a good target for profit taking if we manage to go so far.

We had another entry on cable at 1.8445. Made a high at 1.8484.

Nina

We had another open below EMA50 on Eur / Usd but step stochs still long....hanging around still...

Hi!

Yes, as we see, this is very tough. I think in 20 minutes fed chairman is speaking.

Take care.

Nina

Ok- enough exit at -30 pips, only minimal $$ becuase of risk .