Hi!

Today's recap:

Broker: North Finance Company.

EURUSD, buy at 1.2098. Made a high at 1.2175. +77 pips.

USDCHF, it was in selling mode since yesterday at 1.2785.

GBPUSD, buy at a.7549. Made a high at 1.7721. +172 pips.

TOTAL: +249 pips.

Hi!

I posted broker's name cause I find differences between brokers with StepMa_Stoch.

I use three brokers:
North Finance.
http://www.northfinance.com/main.html

Mig Investments
http://www.migfx.ch/

Neuimex
http://neuimex.com/

Attached one chart of each broker. Look at StepMa_Stoch:

Igorad, What do you think?

Attached Images

	Neuimex.jpg (81.0 KB, 654 views)
	MIG.jpg (97.5 KB, 570 views)
	North Finance.jpg (107.5 KB, 574 views)

Hi, Muram!

Sorry, Muram. It still misses trades!!!

Nina.

Attached Images

CatFx50 indicator.jpg (94.2 KB, 794 views)

Nina,

Correct me if I'm wrong, but it is my understanding this is not a missed trade per the CatFX50 rules that you set forth. The large move which is in your image would not have been a valid move per the rules. I'm attaching an image that shows where the actual cross of the EMA50 happened and it is not validated by StepMA_Stoch. The blue rectangle shows the two bars in which StepMA_Stoch would have had to validate the cross. Do you wish to append the rules any?

Mookfx

Attached Images

CatFx50 indicator.jpg (60.4 KB, 681 views)

Hi, Mookfx!!

Look at where I drew the red arrows. You are right with the blue rectangles. But I pointed to the big move.

And look at North Finance (above)

Nina

Attached Images

Indicator.jpg (210.0 KB, 759 views)

I'll leave the following posted as it may clear up some points, but I was writing it as you were posting your followup above.The issue appears to be in the StepMA_Stoch between brokerages.

Yes, that is my question. The big move is not an entry per the rules of CatFX50 as you have described them. Let me explain.

Per you:

"We buy or sell at the opening of new bar after price has crossed EMA50 and StepMA_Stoch validates the cross. So, if it is a sell, yellow line must be under blue one and viceversa. Signals are better if StepMA_Stoch and price with EMA50 cross at the same time."

So if we are looking at the open for the "big move", does the bar prior to the open of this bar straddle or lay below the EMA50, did the current bar open above EMA50, and does StepMA_Stoch validate. My concern is that Muram's code requires the prior bar to either straddle EMA50 or lay below EMA50. If this is not the case and we just wait for StepMA_Stoch to catch up with EMA50's cross, then Muram's code will need to be modified. Please, correct me if I am wrong as I may have confused some points, but this is how I see it in the strictest sense of the rules of CatFX50.

Mookfx

Nina,

May I contribute?

That is how I interpreted the rules too. Your all important first trigger for a trade is the bar which opens above the 50 ema after one that crosses it IF it is validated by the StepMa....I think that in the above above example the StepMa did not validate so you shouldn't have been in that trade. Am I incorrect or misinterpreted the rules? Thanks.....

mookfx:

We can have as many opening bars above EMA50 (for a buy) as you want. But we do not take that trade unless StepMa_Stoch crosses up.

Let me show you what I say with North Finance¡s chart:

Nina

Attached Images

Example.jpg (154.8 KB, 920 views)

Yes, as I ammended my above post with the note at the top. I think we are cross posting now and I see how the issue can be in StepMA_Stoch between the different brokers. So as I understand now unless we can fix StepMA_Stoch to look the same on every brokers feed, we should ammend Muram's code to trigger signals the happen at the time when both EMA50s cross and StepMA_Stoch meet. This may happen with a few bars lag or lead time on different brokers. To help the situation, the demo account I am testing on is with InterbankFX, so on what is Sunday night for me I will open a demo account with North Finance and the other brokers you have named to test the differences in the CatFX50 signals. I should have some images online by 23PST. For the time being, I'll give the code some work to help Muram out with translating the rules, given he doesn't mind of course. If you have anymore thoughts, let me know and I can try and help incorporate them before the Monday open of market.

Mookfx

EUREKA!!!!

I appreciate your help, mookfx!

It is late for me now. See you!

Nina