Well I run a few copies of Phoenix at the same time. I noticed that on one occassion, AccountA opened a trade one hour before AccountB. Same signal. Account A had SL, AccountB had TP. The deeper question I'm trying to solve is based on signal interpretation. The next version will have a "Debug" level parameter, where Phoenix will spit out tons of Signal data and we can figure out how to make it more reliable.

I don't recall you answering my question from the old (not dead just less focused) thread: did you manually close any trades? I looked at both logs and found that neither SL nor TP was hit on several trades but they exited at a profit. That would be 90% of the answer right there.