View Single Post
  #24 (permalink)  
Old 06-24-2006, 08:41 AM
iGoR's Avatar
iGoR iGoR is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 1,564
iGoR is on a distinguished road
Hy name collegue,

Thanks again for some awsome programming.
I would like to point you to some problem of the NonlagMA.
It shows serious instabillity on different brokers. The NonlagMA used with filter shows great simmularitys with the StepMA7.1 indicator , wich I personnaly find one of the best indicators ever made.
The problem is when introducing this indicator in trading systems on forums, that depending on different brokers, people will have different signals or results. A bit the same problem as some stepmastoch indicator had. That in contrast with the stepMA7.1 wich shows and proof a great stability on different brokers platforms

I posted 2 images of 2 different platforms. 1 of the alpari platform and 1 of the FXDD platform.
I placed the stepMA7.1 indicator on the chart and the NonLagMA on the chart. The 2 platforms have a difference of 1 hour cet. As you can see the StepMA7.1 turns on the 2 chart on the exact same bar from short to long and on the exact same bar from long to short (red vertical lines). The NonlagMa on the other hand goes from short to long on different bars and from long to short again on different bars (green vertical lines). As you can see both NonlagMA have the same values.

So it has nothing to do with different kind of data because the stepMA7.1 turns on exact the same bars were the NonlagMa fails to do this.

Hopefully something can be done to this instability. As I said, otherwise it will be difficult to introduce this indicator in strategys to be backtested or in trading systems because people will all have different results depending on wich broker they use.

Thanks a lott in advance...iGoR
Attached Files
File Type: zip FXDD.zip (130.6 KB, 870 views)

Last edited by iGoR; 06-24-2006 at 09:03 AM.
Reply With Quote