As far as i know (maybe i am wrong) one of the reasons that Igor start thinking about open a private payed room in the first place was that myself and others that have followed him and learned a lot from him ask him to do it.
I can only speak for myself of course but i think the reason for asking was more or less the same for all of us and that was to get away from all the "noise" in the free open rooms.
So if "he should offer one free month to all newbees" then that will be almost as getting back to the free room.
If that happens my main reason for getting in the room in the first place are not valid anymore and i will 100% for sure leave the group when the first free member enter.

When i am here posting i also want to say that so far i have not seen Igor saying anything that are not true about what we do in the group and about the result in the excel sheet.
I have never read or hear him say anything that is a lie ever in any topic. He may be wrong some times of course like all of us, he is not a god, but in my opinion he is very honest.
And about being wrong. As far as i know the result in the excel are correct but i have not been going trough 100% of all the trades in all the excel sheets but i have been going trough many of them and i think other members of the group have done the same so even if there may be some human errors in there they can not be many and not big and they can probably go both ways if there are any so the overall result should be more or less correct over time anyway.
But again i will say that i don't think there are any errors at all and if there are, then they are errors and not scam.

But about the result there are a very important thing that both Igor and others have pointed out that new people may easy forget and that is those results are without spread and slippage and that will make a difference when you compare the excel with what the traders have in the live acc.
There are many trades every day so it is important to remember that.

Another thing that Igor say and that may also be easy for a new trader to forget is that to get the same result you have to take in all the same trades that you see in the excel sheet and do it without errors. That is 10 hours of trading every day.

And if some that reads this do not know, i am a member of the group and i have been there from day one.
I have also been in Igor's free open room from day one. That is around one year.
So i know him well and i can say that he is "the real thing". He is a professional trader, not a scammer and he do all he can to help people succeed in trading!

Arctic4x