... with the possible exception of Pipmaker by donforex IMO

Sure, you can't just start it up and forget about it 'cos a trending market market can kill it dead but it is the best implementation yet that I have seen of this type of robot.

Same goes for gridtrading. I have a version of Makegrid on forward test for over a year now. It has over $10,000 d/d atm but it has I estimate closed at the very least, twice that amount profitably during this time. As it is currently sitting dead-centre in the middle of an 800 pip grid it will likely continue to rake in pips at a nice rate. Just checked, it made $287 dollars yesyerday alone!

Of course the problem with grids is that you need a fairly large account size to begin with and then there's the psychological impact of all that d/d...